Dude, It’s Not About Carbon Dioxide

We know a lot about Carbon dioxide in a jar. We know the wavelengths it prefers to absorb and emit photons. We know it tends to mix efficiently with other gasses. We know it has a nearly magical affinity for cold water.

Spectrum budgetGreenhouse absorbtion spectrum

We have known these things for a long time. What we still do not know is exactly how this gas representing 1/2500 of the atmosphere by volume (1/2000 by mass) acts in the earth’s biogeochemical/atmospheric/oceanic system.

A decade and a half ago when the satellites told us the atmosphere was warming quickly and human Carbon emissions were increasing at about the same slope, it was reasonable to worry. I worried.

Several lines of high quality evidence developed in the last fifteen years now indicate that Carbon dioxide is not a major problem:

1. All four satellite groups agree that there has been little, if any warming of the lower atmosphere in the last sixteen years, in spite of accelerating human CO2 production.


2. Bubbles in ice cores have shown very clearly that atmospheric temperature has led CO2 into and out of every glacial/interglacial cycle at both poles like a poodle on a leash for the last 800,000 years.


3. Multiple  improved measurement techniques indicate that Carbon dioxide the earth’s atmosphere over the history of life has been ten times higher than it is now, and that glacial periods have occurred nonetheless.


4. It has become standard practice to pump CO2 into commercial greenhouses at five times current atmospheric concentration.

5. It has become clear that the rapid warming of the atmosphere documented by satellites from the late seventies to the late nineties is far from unusual and that two periods since the last glaciation experienced equal rates of warming and higher atmospheric temperatures than today.


The hard truth is that we just don’t know how our planet works. Any number of things we are doing may be our undoing, just as any number of things we eat may be killing us. We just don’t know. We will eat, and we will burn, making decisions at every turn with imperfect information. We must use science to give us the best possible edge, and right now all the evidence is saying, “Dude, it’s not about Carbon dioxide”

This entry was posted in Carbon Cycle, Carbon Dioxide Loves to Swim, Climate, Climate Change, Global Warming, Paleoclimate and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.